Stepbrother Desire (Erotica)

“Last night wasn’t the first time, was it?” Ashley said. “Nor was Beth the first one. Oh, I see. Well now, just how many of your sisters are you fucking Mike?”

Sarah turned towards Mike and glared at him. “She didn’t know you were fucking us too, you big idiot.”

Mike stared dumbly at her for a second, and then felt his face grow red from embarrassment.

“Like I said… what she said. You’re an idiot.”

“Sorry,” he said.

“You’re fucking all of your sisters?” Ashley said, with her mouth and both eyes wide.

Emma turned to regard Ashley. “Ash, don’t judge us. You don’t know anything about what caused all of this, or how we feel, or how it feels to be with our brother. He’s the perfect lover, and it all… just… happened.”

“You think…” Mike started.

“Shut up,” Emma growled at him and he fell silent.

Ashley was quiet for a minute while she processed the new information.

Then she suddenly smiled and looked around at the family. “I’ll not judge, I promise. I’ve always been mildly attracted to my own older brother. But, it was always a secret I kept to myself, a fantasy of sorts, something I’d never act on. I’m actually, kinda… envious of you guys. Makes me wish I was a sister of Mike’s too.”NôvelDrama.Org © 2024.

The sisters chuckled, and the mood lightened in the room, a little.

Danni looked at her, concern still on her face, “Look, I need my brother. Something happened a few months ago that I’d rather not talk about. He’s my brother, yes. But he’s also my lover,” she said, “And my knight in shining armor.” She smiled at him as he looked back at her, touched. “I wasn’t able to sleep at all last night,” she said to him, a wistful smile on her face. “I can’t wait to snuggle up to you tonight.”

Mike smiled. The day had barely even started, and he was already anxious for bedtime.

“We still have stuff to discuss you guys,” Sarah said, drawing them back into the conversation. “I think I’ve got a solution to everyone’s problems.”

Five heads turned and looked at the eldest sister, curious as to what she was going to say.

“Okay, Mike is sleeping with his sisters,” Sarah began, “Society frowns on that, and we need to keep quiet. With school starting soon, it’s going to look odd if Mike keeps turning down dates, especially him not having a girlfriend. People might start to think that you’ve started playing for the other team.”

They all laughed at the statement, but continued to listen intently as Sarah continued. “Ashley is head over heels for our baby brother, and has a bit of leverage over us now to boot.”

“I wouldn’t tell anyone, ever,” Ashley said, “I love you guys too much,” smiling over at Emma.

“Just the same,” said Sarah, “we need to make sure that you don’t have any reason to tell anyone.”

“Just spit it out Sarah,” Danni said, guessing at what she was going to say.

Sarah cleared her throat and took a deep breath. “I think Mike needs to start publicly dating Ashley. That would clear up any question as to who was with him last night in the minds of our friends, and it also gives the five of us a cover story, as well as giving Ashley a reason to keep our little secret.”

A silence fell over the group as they processed the idea.

“That sounds reasonable to me. Hell, the more pussy the better.”

‘Yeah, you would,’ he thought.

“I can go along with that,” said Ashley.

“Ya think?” replied Emma.

“Do I get a say in this?” Mike asked, glancing around.

“No, you don’t.” Emma said, drawing a laugh from the other five girls. “You stand to gain the most you big doofus. You get another girl to be with, someone you can actually go do things with. Movies, dinner, picnics at the beach, etc, etc… and we all get to keep fucking your brains out. Ashley gets a boyfriend, with the same fringe benefits.”

“As long as everyone can share,” Ashley said quietly, glancing around. “I don’t just want him once a month or so. If he’s going to be my boyfriend, we have to actually start doing things together besides the obvious. But I promise I won’t try and have him more than any of you.”

Mike sighed as he tried to wrap his mind around all the subjects contained inside the conversation that was progressing around him.

“Do you think we need to work out a schedule?” Sarah asked, but the others were shaking their heads.

“That’s part of what makes sex with him so much fun. You never know when he’ll be in the mood, or when he’ll just attack you in the shower,” Emma said, grinning.

Beth blushed and giggled at that, remembering how dangerous it had been in the shower for her and Mike.

The other four turned and looked at her, though Mike was lost in thought and staring off into space. “Long story.” she said, a small smile on her lips.

“So, we’re all in agreement then,” Danni said. “Mike and Ashley are a couple to anyone on the outside looking in. In return, she doesn’t tell a single living soul, ever.”

Everyone nodded, except for Mike. He was still staring off into space, looking like his usual idiot self.

“Mike!” Sarah said, loudly.

He shook his head back to reality, and turned looking at his sisters. “What?”

Sarah sighed, turning to Ashley. “He agrees, trust me.”

“Oh, yeah, I’m sorry. I agree,” he said, coming back to the conversation.

They talked politely for a few minutes before Ashley stood to go. “Well, I guess you need to call me sometime soon,” Ashley said, smiling at Mike.

He stood and walked around to her. “Let me walk you out,” he said, starting towards the door.

“I’d like that,” she said, smiling as he put his arm around her.